What it was. What
it became. What it is today.
by: J.F. (Jim) Straw
To begin with ...
Multi-Level Distribution Is As Old As Business
If it weren't for the Multi-Level Distribution of products
throughout the world and across this nation, you would have to
travel to Battle Creek to get a box of breakfast cereal ... to
Switzerland to buy a fine wristwatch ... to Detroit to buy a
car ... to California or Florida to buy orange juice ... to Mexico
to get a Taco ... (you get the picture).
Multi-Level Distribution systems are dependent upon each level
buying and reselling the products for their own account. - That,
of course, requires capital investments in warehousing and distribution
facilities, in addition to the cost of the inventory.
Owing to the (sometimes massive) capital costs involved in
establishing the necessary warehousing and distribution facilities
inherent in Multi-Level Distribution systems, small manufacturers
were often limited to selling their products only within their
limited surrounding area.
That lead to the eventual creation of ...
Multi-Level Marketing As It Was!
Long before William Penn Patrick's Holiday Magic Cosmetics
(which I sold) ... even though it wasn't called Multi-Level Marketing
... Raleigh Products, Fuller Brushes, Watkins Products, and Avon
Cosmetics (all of which I have also sold) were sold through warehousing
distributors, area distributors, sub-distributors, dealers and
finally retailers (with varying names for each level; of course).
In companies like those mentioned, the money flowed up from
the retailer; ultimately to the manufacturer, with each level
in-between taking their share off-the-top, filling the order
and then replenishing their inventory by buying from the next
higher level. Each level was clearly defined by the amount of
product actually purchased and inventoried by the person on that
level. Throughout the marketing levels, the emphasis was always
on selling the product. Each level was structured to provide
speedy deliver of the product to the end-user. - Of course, to
eliminate the problem of salesmen absconding with the sample
cases and samples, most of the companies required that the cases
and samples be purchased ... up the same levels of distribution.
If a distributor's sub-distributors didn't sell enough product,
the distributor still had to buy enough inventory from the next
higher level to keep and maintain their distributor status. -
That meant the distributor had to reach into their pocket and
buy inventory for future sales. So, each level pushed the lower
levels to sell more product.
The first Multi-Level Marketing companies (as we know them
today) were a take-off on this method of marketing. - Those companies
were designed and intended to take a manufacturer's products
directly to the consumer market ... in volume ... rapidly.
But, the emphasis was changed from selling the product to
recruiting more and more and more sales people. - Why? - Because
it was logical to assume that if 100 sales people, making just
one sale each per month, could sell 100 of a product - then -
10,000 sales people, making just one sale each per month, would
sell 10,000 of a product. - The more sales people, the more sales.
In order to make recruiting sales people profitable, the originators
of the first programs paid a commission for each 'dealer' recruited
... whether that person every sold anything or not. They did,
however, require that each 'dealer' buy a minimum amount of product
... or recruit an established number of new 'dealers' ... each
month to qualify for commissions from all of the 'dealers' they
had recruited, and those recruited by those 'dealers,' and those
recruited by those 'dealers,' etc., etc., etc.
Did you notice that I changed from hiring sales people to
recruiting dealers? - That's because dealers don't have to sell
The money to pay those commissions came from the "fees"
a person had to pay to become a dealer ... the higher the level
you bought into, the higher the "fees" you paid, and
the higher your commissions on the "fees" paid by the
dealers you recruited ... with on-going commissions coming from
the required monthly purchases made by those who stayed in the
program (if there were any). - Of course, you didn't have to
buy the minimum amount of product inventory if you recruited
enough new dealers each month ... from which you earned your
Later, when laws were passed outlawing the payment of commissions
based on "dealer fees," the promoters simply reduced
the dealer fees to token amounts (or nothing) and began paying
the commissions on the sales of sample cases and samples ...
which, if you didn't sell any, you didn't earn any commissions.
What Multi-Level Marketing Became!
In the beginning, Multi-Level Marketing was designed and intended
to take a manufacturer's products directly to the consumer market
... in volume ... rapidly. - That is still its highest and best
purpose, when it is the true and real goal of the marketing company
(which is rarely the case anymore). However ...
It didn't take long for the less-than-scrupulous marketers
to learn that they could expand a company's sales exponentially,
overnight, by simply selling sample cases and samples ... even
if none of the product ever got into the hands of the consumer,
the company's sales volume was excellent.
That's when all kinds of marketing consultants began promoting
establishing Multi-Level Marketing divisions within companies
which were desperate for sales. - That, in turn, is ...
How Multi-Level Marketing Programs Began Violating the
First Law of Business!
The First Law of Business is ...
Demand Creates Supply!
(Not the other way around.)
To explain. -- If 1,000,000 people want (or need) Purple Widgets,
in accord with the First Law of Business, someone, somewhere,
somehow will create Purple Widgets to meet that demand. -- The
demand creates the supply.
On the other hand, if you had 1,000,000 Purple Widgets in
your warehouse, but no one wanted them, those Purple Widgets
would be worthless. -- A supply alone can not create a demand.
Although the First Law of Business states that "Demand
Creates Supply," it wasn't long before some of the marketing
consultants discovered that they could sell almost anything ...
even if it was a product for which there was NO demand (your
warehouse filled with Purple Widgets) ... by simply creating
a Multi-Level Marketing Program and selling tons and tons of
a product no one wanted "in sample cases". - Then,
when the dealers (sample-case-buyers) dried-up, the promoters
simply moved-on to another company.
Occasionally ... as luck would have it ... an unknown 'demand'
would be found and a product would find a true market; after
the Multi-Level Marketing Program had died. But, usually, when
the Multi-Level Marketing Program died, so did the company. -
Some of them walked-away with a bundle of money from the sales
of their 'sample-case-products.' -- Most lost all the money they
had accumulated from their 'sample-case' sales by trying to reestablish
a perceived 'demand' that didn't exist.
Today, the Multi-Level Marketing promoters are in ...
Full Compliance with the First Law of Business!
But, instead of supplying the products and services demanded
by the public, they are ...
Supplying Multi-Level Marketing Programs to Multi-Level
That's right, you don't even need a real product or service
today. All you have to have is a Multi-Level Marketing Program.
Being an ol'professional Mailorder Marketer, I have had the
pleasure of personally knowing some of the real, honest promoters
and marketers who employ Multi-Level Marketing methods to sell
their products and services.
On the other hand, I have also been thrown into close personal
contact with those Multi-Level Marketing promoters who are less
than scrupulous ... meaning they have no qualms about taking
people's money under false pretenses (which, unfortunately, is
the vast majority of the MLM promoters of today).
Note: In the Multi-Level Marketing industry
of today, people who buy into the programs are always referred
to as "mooches." Thus, those of us who have "been
there, done that, bought the T-shirt" very often refer to
M-L-M as "Mooches Losing Money."
Anywho, as one of those Multi-Level Marketing promoter once
told me, he just keeps creating and selling "hot-air sandwiches."
- Once the 'dealers' figure out it's a "hot-air sandwich,"
he just wraps his "hot-air sandwiches" in a new Multi-Level
Marketing program ... with a new name, from a new location ...
and sells them to the same "mooches" all over again.
(His words, not mine.)
But -- that's not the reason ...
Why over 90% of the people who get involved in
Multi-Level Marketing programs fail miserably!
Although I have made a bundle of money selling multi-level
products ... believe it or don't ... I have never been involved
in Multi-Level Marketing.
Back when I was a very young man, my Daddy told me ...
Never Ask Anyone To Do Anything For You That You
Could Not Or Would Not Do For Yourself!
Of course, when my Daddy told me that I thought (at first)
it was about the dumbest thing I had ever heard. As a matter
of fact, my initial response was a little flippant ... "What
about having a baby?"
His answer opened my eyes and my mind ...
"Son, I didn't say you had to be able to do everything
you ask people to do for you. I said not to ask anyone to do
anything that you either could not or would not do for yourself.
If you ask a young lady to have a baby for you, it should be
when you would be willing to have a baby for her, if you could.
If you aren't ready and willing to take the responsibility for
(have) the baby yourself, don't ask her to do it for you."
Living that sage advice, throughout my over 40 years (man
and boy) career as an entrepreneur, whenever I came across a
product I wanted to sell ... even a multi-level product ... I
sold it myself. - I never put any effort into "recruiting"
dealers ... I just sold the products. Then, if one of my customers
did become a dealer, I earned the resulting "downline"
commissions from their sales.
You Can't Even Do That Today!
Back when I made real money selling Multi-Level products,
the "sales person" who sold the product (me) earned
the lions-share of the commissions ... usually 33% to 50% of
the "retail" price. And, even though the products were
sold through a Multi-Level Marketing plan, the products were
"legitimately priced" for the consumer market.
Today, the "commission" paid to the person who makes
a real sale of the product is so low ... commonly 10% to 15%
... the advertising cost alone would devour every penny you earned
in direct sales commissions. And ...
In order to pay 10% to 15% commissions on 3 to 5 levels, the
"retail prices" of the products are so over-inflated,
the only person you could hope to sell the product to would be
someone who wanted to "buy a dealership" ... not the
As a matter of fact ...
You Can't Even "Buy" Multi-Level Products
"What?" you say ... "That's right," I
Every month, I receive hundreds upon hundreds of Multi-Level
Marketing offers. - Last week, I received 37 in the mail; 53
by FAX; and over 100 by e-mail ... Guess What?
Not one of the offers I received even tried to sell me their
product. - In every case, in order to "buy" the product,
I had to "sign-up" to be a dealer. - Most of the offers
didn't even tell me what the product was ... just a "get-rich-quick"
come-on alluding to the product by its brand-name or generic
description. The only thing they were selling was the right to
sell somebody else the right to sell somebody else the right
to sell the right to sell the right ... ad nauseam.
Even those companies that did have a seemingly real product
didn't offer to sell that product to me. They only offered me
the "opportunity" to sign-up as a dealer.
Now ... since I know for a fact that a 'few' of you are involved
in "MLM" ... let me explain the facts of business life
YES! There are MLM companies that do (or at least 'pretend'
to) attempt to sell their products - but - their "dealers"
don't. The "good intentions" of the company are shot
to hell by the "dealers" who only see the downline
commissions. The "dealers" couldn't care less whether
or not they sell any products ... as long as they recruit and
enroll more dealers. - After all, that's the name of the MLM
game. - And, when there are no more dealers to be found for their
current offering, they move on to the next "hot-air sandwich"
... even if it has a seemingly real product to sell.
So, here's ...
THE REAL REASON
Why over 90% of the people who get involved in
Multi-Level Marketing programs fail miserably!
As I told you earlier, in order to satisfy the First Law of
Business, instead of supplying the products and services demanded
by the public, the MLM companies are only ...
Supplying Multi-Level Marketing Programs to Multi-Level
But ... the number of people involved in Multi-Level Marketing
is a limited universe. It can only survive by finding "new
mooches" to buy "hot-air sandwiches." Because,
after a "mooch" has bought into a number of "hot-air
sandwiches," he or she quits and a "newer mooch"
has to be found. Because, sooner or later, they will learn, for
a fact ...
There Ain't No Free Lunch!
Because the MLM companies are selling the Free Lunch Dream,
every month I get at least a dozen letters proclaiming: "With
your loyal customer base you could make yourself a fortune by
marketing my program." - After all, they "know"
that, if they can get me to sell the program for them, they will
"get filthy rich" from my efforts (not their own) ...
just like the big-boys in MLM told them they would.
But, let me tell you about the big-boys ... heavy hitters
... in MLM who, without hesitation, show you their big checks
as 'proof' that YOU can make big money in their MLM program.
Let's pretend that a "heavy hitter" shows you his
check for $10,000 from the MLM company he is promoting. -- What
he doesn't tell you is that he has 1,000 people in his "downline"
... each generating a $10 commission for him - but - those 1,000
people are only making $10 each (usually spending $50 to do so).
But, you say, "My 'sponsor' is gonna put people in my
Okay, here's how that works. -- In those programs, they use
an inverted pay scale ... you earn very small commissions on
your own sales and the commissions get higher and higher the
deeper the downline goes (sometimes to 9 levels). -- It is designed
to make your mouth-water when you see how much you can make on
the 5th (or 6th) level if you only get one (just one) dealer
on your first line.
On the other hand, the "heavy hitter" doesn't want
to put people on his top line ... he wants to give them to you
so they appear on his 3rd, 4th, 5th, or even 6th lines; where
the commissions are the highest. -- You get the itty-bitty commissions
while the "heavy hitter" gets the big commissions from
the deeper levels he "gives" to you.
The odds of you ever getting people down to your 4th, 5th
or 6th levels are slim and none because, nobody will stay with
the program long enough for you to benefit from the higher commissions;
while your heavy-hitter sponsor is already collecting at those
levels because he gave you his first line sale.
Right now, you're probably thinking "Boy howdy! Ol'Jim
sure hates MLM."
Wrong, hot-air sandwich breath. - Ol'Jim hates what MLM has
become. - A real Multi-Level Marketing company, employing real
sales people, with the real intent and purpose of taking a manufacturer's
products directly to the consumer market ... in volume ... rapidly
... is still a viable and effective method of marketing. -- There
just aren't very many real Multi-Level Marketing companies, today.
But ... if you have the stomach for it ...
You Can Get Rich In Multi-Level Marketing!
If you have no qualms about taking people's money under false
pretenses ... can stomach telling people that they will make
outrageous amounts of money (knowing full well they won't) ...
without working ... by getting other people to do the work for
them - or - "We do the work for you!" ... without selling
anything ... just by "recruiting" others ... all you
have to do is develop your own personal customer base of Multi-Level
Marketers ... like the heavy-hitter have.
Then, keep your customer base supplied with more and More
and MORE Multi-Level Marketing Programs ... the only "product"
your customers are really buying.
But ... keep in mind ...
Hype Only Produces Hype Customers!
Where over 80% of my customers stay with me year after year,
you will have to accept the fact that, in the case of "hype
customers," you will lose 80% of your customer base each
year and have to replace those people with new "hype customers"
("mooches" in the vernacular of the industry).
That's the way the "heavy-hitters" in MLM have done
it and are doing it even today. - You can do it, too - but -
do it with the knowledge of what you are doing ... don't start
believing the "hype" yourself.
As for me, I like to sleep well at night, secure in the knowledge
that the products I have sold today will, without equivocation,
assist my customers in their search for prosperity. -- I can't
honestly do that with the Multi-Level Marketing programs on the
"Count no day lost in which you waited your turn,
took only your share, and sought advantage over no one."
- Robert Brault
For information you can convert to real business knowledge,
check out our "Power Tools for Entrepreneurs."
the Record -
My first experience with MLM was wa-a-a-ay back ... with William
Penn Patrick's Holiday Magic. At the time, I was selling "Avon"
(I was a ding-dong Avon "lady" out in the farm lands
of Kansas) at the time.
Holiday Magic was as good as Avon but their commissions were
better, so I picked up the line. Then, I started getting extra
commission checks when some of my satisfied customers bought
into the opportunity.
Some years later, I signed up for the "Koscot Interplanetary
Cosmetics" Mink Oil line (Glenn Turner). -- At the time,
I owned a chain of Women's Wig Shops across the Southeast and
simply wanted to sell the cosmetics in my shops. -- The first
month, the girls who managed my wig shops turned in over $25,000
worth of orders from the counter displays I had installed in
each of the shops. BUT ... I couldn't buy any of the cosmetics
from Koscot. All of the cosmetics were being used up to
make sales kits so there were none left over to "retail."
In 1978 (or was it 1979), I sold "subscriptions"
to the first business opps newsletter sold by MLM. -- I just
sold subscriptions to a good newsletter ... the customers signed
up for the opportunity ... I was making over $20,000 per month;
even after the newsletter quit publishing (which put the company
out of business for accepting payment for something they weren't
The article I wrote was after being approached by literally
DOZENS of promoters wanting me to help them create MLM plans
for their products. -- That's when I learned what the industry
was becoming. -- None of them really wanted to sell their
products. All they wanted was to "do a MLM" to
make some big bucks. -- Unfortunately, that experience threw
me into personal contact with some of the big name MLM con-men
and left a very bad taste in my marketing mouth.
I feel the new generation of "opportunity seekers"
need to know what they will be dealing with in the vast majority
of MLM deals.
Return to the Table of Contents
You may contact me directly by Mail or eMail at ...
J.F. (Jim) Straw
Dalton, GA 30720-8029
Be sure to mention
you saw it in the Business Lyceum.
Copyright - 2005, J.F. (Jim) Straw. All rights reserved.